Text size

Colors

Triple Test: Mercedes E Class All Terrain v Audi A6 Allroad v Volvo V90 Cross Country

Triple Test: Mercedes E Class All Terrain v Audi A6 Allroad v Volvo V90 Cross Country

By Swansway Motor Group 31-08-2018

20 views

If you’re after an estate car with a little more go-anywhere ability, then one of these three could be for you. We test out a trio of off-road estate big-hitters

Is one of these 4x4 estate cars for you?

In the age of the crossover, compact SUV and four-door coupes, there’s still space for the estate car. However, what if you want a little extra off-road capability with your ‘wagon’? Then step this way; our trio here cater for exactly that market.

The Audi A6 Allroad, Mercedes E-Class All-Terrain and Volvo V90 Cross Country feature raised ride heights, chunky exterior bodywork and strong, workhorse-like diesel engines designed to make them better over rough terrain than their ‘regular’ estate counterparts. We’re here to see which one tops the bill and, in the face of so many niche vehicles, whether they still have a place.

Black Audi A6 Allroad driving towards you in the rain


What’s new?

In terms of ‘newness’, the Audi falls short here. The latest-generation A6 has just been announced, making this version here the ‘old’ car. But that’s no reason to discount it – it still has one of the very best interiors around in terms of quality, while the exterior design is still pretty today.

The E-Class All-Terrain, meanwhile, is one of the latest ‘off-road’ estates to hit the market. Based on the regular – and excellent – E-Class Estate, this All Terrain has one of the best-looking cabins available today as well one of the largest boots in the segment – dog owners rejoice!

Think Volvos are stuffy, elbow patch-housing barges of yesteryear? You need only look at the V90 Cross Country to realise this isn’t the case anymore. With an interior dripping in Scandinavian simplicity and an exterior which makes it stand out from the crowd, the Cross Country is anything but boring.


What’s under the bonnet?

Given that these three rather heavy estates are designed to cope – and return the best economy – across longer journeys and motorway schleps, it’s understandable that they all feature large, turbocharged diesel engines.

The Audi features a 3.0-litre twin-turbocharged V6 diesel with an impressive 320bhp delivered to all four wheels with its famed Quattro system. It can hit 60mph in under five-and-a-half seconds, before topping out at 155mph. Despite this, Audi claims that it’ll return 43.5mpg on the combined cycle, while emitting 172g/km CO2.

The Mercedes also utilises a 3.0-litre turbocharged diesel, paired with Merc’s 4MATIC all-wheel-drive system via a nine-speed automatic gearbox, but it can’t quite match the Audi for outright power, producing 245bhp. The sprint to 60mph takes 6.2 seconds, but features the same 155mph top speed as the Audi. Its claimed 47mpg figure does trump the A6’s, however, though its 179g/km CO2 emissions are a touch poorer.

Finally we come to the Volvo. Here, it uses the D5 powertrain, which sees a 2.0-litre turbocharged diesel engine under the bonnet sending 230bhp to all four wheels. It’s the least powerful and also the slowest here, taking 8.3 seconds to hit 60mph before reaching a top speed of 140mph but, where it lacks in power, it more than makes up for in economy. Volvo claims that the V90 Cross Country will return 62.8mpg on the combined cycle, as well as emitting just 119g/km CO2 – easily the best results of the three.

Merceds E Class All-Terrain driving towards you in the rain


What are they like to drive?

As large, relatively heavy estate cars, you wouldn’t expect this trio to offer the last word in exciting driving experiences. Thanks to a raised ride height and more off-road orientated suspension setups, they aren’t as involving to drive as their tarmac-focused counterparts, but still offer a decent enough drive to keep the average motorist happy.

The Volvo’s steering is well weighted and makes piloting the car – given its size – particularly hassle-free, even through tighter urban environments. The Mercedes’, in contrast, is the most agile-feeling of the three, with sharper handling giving you better opportunities to exploit the car in faster bends. The Audi’s handling is – surprise, surprise – typical of the German marque; it’s dependable and the whole car feels planted through corners, as well as at higher speeds on the motorway.

As you’d expect from the engine outputs, the Audi easily feels the quickest here. Presses of the throttle are accompanied by a close-to-V8 rumble, and an impressively good turn of pace. That said, the Mercedes isn’t far behind – and the nine-speed automatic gearbox shifts smoothly throughout the cogs. Though the Volvo is the least powerful of the three, it never feels underpowered out on the road, only struggling to gain pace when travelling at higher speeds.


How do they look?

All three here are chunkier takes on the regular estate cars they are based on and, in our eyes at least, really do look quite good. The Audi’s exterior design may be the oldest here – with a new version of the regular A6 due to arrive this year – but it still looks sleek. Its dimensions have always proved popular, and somehow it always manages to just look ‘right’ when out on the road.

The Volvo’s design is typically Scandinavian – refined, minimalistic and effortlessly stylish. The ‘Thor’s Hammer’ headlights remain a crucial style feature, while the extra body cladding of the Cross Country does help beef-up the looks of the V90. Despite being a large car, it doesn’t appear too oversized in the metal, either.

The E-Class All-Terrain closest resembles to the ‘regular’ car, particularly in the metallic silver colour of our test car. It looks to the most modern of the three, certainly, but the long overhangs at front and rear can make it look a little dumpy. It’s certainly a better car in darker shades, or colours such as metallic red.

Volvo V90 Cross Country driving towards you in the rain


What’s are they like inside?

Of the three, the Volvo takes the crown here. It’s not that the other two are sub-standard – far from it – it’s just that the V90 Cross Country’s cabin feels the highest-quality, despite being the most minimalistic here. The large iPad-style central infotainment dominates the car’s forward area, and it’s accompanied by useful amount of manual controls.

The Audi’s interior architecture may be quite old compared to the other two here, but that doesn’t stop it from being a pleasant place to be. The infotainment screen is small by modern standards, and the satellite navigation isn’t that detailed, but it’s simple to navigate and it’s a breeze to connect your phone too. The seats are brilliantly supportive, while the driving position remains spot-on.

The most notable feature in the Merc’s cabin is the ultra-wide infotainment display. It helps elevate the look of the interior, and is backed up by a series of high-quality toggle switches too. That said, some plastics lower down are of a poorer quality, but this is the same across Mercedes’ range of cars.


What’s the spec like?

As you’d expect with large, premium estate cars, there’s a lot of equipment included as standard. The A6 benefits from Audi’s full sound system, as well as DAB digital radio and full Bluetooth smartphone connectivity. Four-zone air conditioning is fitted as standard too. In terms of exterior touches, the Allroad gets full xenon headlights with LED daytime running lights, as well as 18-inch alloy wheels.

As standard, the Cross Country has the previously mentioned central infotainment screen, along with an eight-inch TFT driver’s information screen. Leather-faced seats are fitted, which are heated in the front too – a real plus when the weather turns colder. In addition, you get 17-inch alloy wheels and Pilot Assist – Volvo’s semi-autonomous driving assistance system.

The Mercedes features a range of standard equipment, with highlights including Apple CarPlay and Android Auto smartphone connectivity, as well as the excellent Burmester surround sound system which provides an excellent tone. Large 20-inch alloy wheels are fitted as standard too, helping give the car a lot of presence.


Verdict

It’s certainly apparent that all three cars here are excellent at providing just a little more security in poor conditions than classic estates, while also delivering a cosseting and comfortable driving experience – but which comes out on top?

As capable and solidly built as the Audi is, it can’t quite come up trumps here. We’ve already seen the new A6, and that’s no bad thing – the A6 Allroad just feels a little outdated in this company, particularly in terms of in-car technology and general cabin design.

We then come to the Mercedes and Volvo. Both are impressive to look at both inside and out, and both deal with the rougher stuff better than there more road-focused counterparts. But we’ve got to give this victory to the E-Class. It’s just a little keener to drive, has a bit more presence out on the road and features one of the most beautiful infotainment screen setups we’ve seen. The Volvo’s no bad choice, mind you – it just gets edged by the E-Class ever so slightly.

Design your own Audi A6 Allroad


 

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more